Blog / Guides

Otterly vs Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit

Allan de Wit · · 5 min read

Otterly is a dedicated AI search monitoring tool with a free trial. Semrush adds AI visibility to its SEO suite. Here is how they differ on engines, prompts and access.

A professional holding a laptop by an office window
Summarize with

Otterly and the Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit both help you see how your brand appears in AI answers, but they come from different places. Otterly is a dedicated AI search monitoring tool with a free trial. Semrush offers AI visibility inside its SEO platform. The better fit mostly depends on whether you already work in Semrush and want one login, or want a dedicated tool you can try first.

We read Otterly's pricing page and FAQ and Semrush's AI SEO page and help center in November 2026; the claims below are theirs, and we say where. Plans and engine lists shift often, so confirm with each vendor. Prices are left out deliberately.

The two tools in brief

Otterly tracks prompts across AI engines and reports brand visibility, sentiment, share of voice and citation sources. Its pricing page lists unlimited brands, competitors, countries and team members on every plan. For a wider view, see our best Otterly alternatives and the Pineprompt vs Otterly page.

Semrush treats AI visibility as an extension of SEO. Its toolkit adds reports such as Prompt Tracking, Brand Performance and an AI Search Site Audit to an account many marketing teams already pay for. For a wider view of the Semrush side, see our Semrush AI Toolkit alternatives.

Engines covered

Otterly's pricing page lists seven engines: ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot, Google AI Mode, Google Gemini and Claude, with more coming soon. Otterly says every plan can use every engine, with each engine consuming credits, and its plan table shows 3 of the 7 engines selected at a time. The page also says each Claude answer counts as 3 credits, because Otterly says analysing Claude costs it three times as much.

For Semrush, the engine depends on the report. The AI SEO page lists ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode as data sources, while a Prompt Tracking campaign offers ChatGPT Search, AI Mode and Gemini.

On paper Otterly reaches further: Perplexity, Copilot and Claude are on its list and not on Semrush's.

Prompts and refresh

Otterly's plans are measured in credits: its FAQ says one credit is one prompt checked once on one AI engine, so a prompt tracked daily on one engine uses 31 credits a month. The pricing page lists 20, 160 and 535 prompts on Lite, Standard and Premium, and tracking is daily, with weekly checking available on Premium.

Semrush counts prompts, not credits. Its help center caps the standalone toolkit at 25 tracked prompts; the Semrush One bundles raise that to 50, 100 or 200. Semrush's AI SEO page says Prompt Tracking data is updated daily, Brand Performance reports weekly and Visibility Overviews monthly (its knowledge base describes some reports as updating daily).

Otterly lists Share of Voice KPIs among its analytics. Semrush's Prompt Tracking article says Share of Voice is not available for the AI engines in Prompt Tracking at this time; it appears in Brand Performance reports. If you are weighing how to build a prompt set, our methodology explains how we think about it.

Data access

Otterly's pricing page lists API and MCP access from its Standard plan, with monthly request limits that rise on Premium. Semrush's knowledge base lists CSV exports as part of the standalone toolkit, and it has separate help pages for its API. We could not confirm from the pages we read which of those apply to the AI Visibility Toolkit, so ask Semrush.

What else you get

Both include a site-readiness check. Otterly's pricing page lists a GEO Audit with a crawlability check and a content check. Semrush says its AI Search Site Audit checks AI crawlability.

Beyond that, Semrush brings keyword research and traditional site audits into the same account. Otterly is focused on AI search monitoring, so if you need a full SEO suite you would pair it with another tool.

How you buy

Otterly's pricing page says it provides a free trial for new users. Semrush's knowledge base and AI SEO page both say the AI Visibility Toolkit has no free trial, though Semrush offers a demo.

Which to pick

  • You pay for Semrush already and want AI data beside your keyword work: start with its toolkit.
  • You need Perplexity, Copilot or Claude listed: Otterly.
  • You want more tracked prompts without a suite: Otterly lists up to 535 on Premium.
  • You want to test before paying: Otterly offers a free trial; Semrush says the toolkit has none.

Where Pineprompt fits

Like Otterly, Pineprompt is focused on monitoring rather than a full SEO suite. Prompts run daily on five live engines (ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode), and each answer is scored for mentions, position, sentiment, cited sources and share of voice. Plans are counted in prompts rather than credits. MCP access comes with every plan, and Professional and Business add the API and Looker Studio. We do not offer a free trial, but you can sign up without a card and see what the engines say about you before you choose a plan.

Skip it if you want keyword research or site audits under the same login. For side-by-side pages, see Pineprompt vs Otterly and Pineprompt vs Semrush, or see the pricing page. You may also like Profound vs Semrush and Peec AI vs Semrush.

Written by

Allan de Wit

Co-founder & Head of Product

Allan co-founded Pineprompt and leads its product. He writes about how AI platforms pick the brands they cite, and what teams can do to earn those mentions.

Keep reading

Track your brand across every AI platform.

Pineprompt monitors five live AI platforms daily, in the country and language your buyers use. See our methodology for what we capture and how.