Blog / Guides

Scrunch vs AthenaHQ for AI visibility

Allan de Wit · · 6 min read

Scrunch and AthenaHQ both go beyond monitoring, but they meter usage differently and list different engines on their entry plans. Here is how they compare.

A woman in black stands in a server-room corridor holding a laptop, with racks of networking equipment lit in blue behind a glass wall
Summarize with

Scrunch and AthenaHQ both show how your brand appears in answers from AI search engines, and both pair that monitoring with tools for acting on it. They differ in how they limit usage and in what they list on the plan you can start on. Scrunch counts prompts and responses, and lists site audits, agent traffic analytics and agent-optimized pages. AthenaHQ counts credits, where one credit is one AI response, and lists unlimited topics and prompts, content recommendations and optimization agents.

This comparison draws on each vendor's public pricing page as we read it in November 2026, plus our own compare pages for Scrunch and AthenaHQ. Vendors change their products often, so confirm details with them before you buy. We do not quote either vendor's prices here, so check the pricing pages for current figures. Where a statement is the vendor's own claim, we say so.

The two tools in brief

Scrunch's pricing page lists two plans for brands, Core and Enterprise, with a separate For agencies view, and says Scrunch is trusted by 500+ leading brands and agencies. For a closer look at it against another monitoring tool, see Peec AI vs Scrunch.

AthenaHQ lists three plans: Essential, Starter and Enterprise. Essential is free, Starter is listed as best for self-guided SMBs, and Enterprise is custom. The page describes its Athena AI agent, content recommendations and a content optimization agent alongside the monitoring. We compared it with another tool in AthenaHQ vs Profound.

Engines covered

Scrunch's pricing page lists four engines on Core: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AIO and Copilot. Enterprise lists nine, adding Claude, Gemini, Meta AI, Google AI Mode and Grok.

AthenaHQ's free Essential plan lists five engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Gemini and Copilot. Starter lists eleven, adding AI Mode, Claude, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral, and the page says additional models are available on request.

If Claude, Gemini or AI Mode matter to you, Scrunch's page places them on its custom-priced Enterprise plan, whereas AthenaHQ's page lists them on Starter.

Limits: prompts, responses and credits

Scrunch Core lists 125 unique prompts and 5,000 responses collected a month, with one country, one persona, one language and five competitors. Enterprise lists custom prompts and responses, unlimited countries, and custom personas, languages and competitors. Scrunch's pricing page does not list a run cadence.

AthenaHQ meters usage in credits. Its pricing page lists 300 credits on Essential and 3,600 credits a month on Starter, with one credit equal to one AI response and a one-month credit rollover on Starter. Starter lists unlimited topics, prompts and competitors, and country-level support. Extra credits are a paid add-on, and Enterprise credits are negotiated in the contract.

Site and content tools

Scrunch's pricing page lists site audits (five a month on Core, full audits on Enterprise), a 25-page site map on Core, AI agent and bot traffic analytics, one page optimization a month on Core with basic content generation, and AXP (Agent Experience Platform) on Enterprise.

AthenaHQ's pricing page lists a content optimization agent and on-page and off-page actions on Starter, and Shopify, Webflow, GA4 and Search Console integrations.

Data access and integrations

Scrunch's pricing page lists Looker Studio and Query API access on Enterprise, with MCP access shown as custom. It lists support channels as email on Core and email plus Slack on Enterprise.

AthenaHQ's Starter plan lists data export to CSV, and API access is an add-on billed on top of the subscription. Its pricing page also lists an executive dashboard with BI tool support (Tableau, Power BI, Looker) on Enterprise. AthenaHQ's pricing page does not list MCP access.

Trial and buying process

Scrunch lists a seven-day free trial on Core and a Get a demo route for Enterprise. AthenaHQ lists Essential as free, with 300 credits included, and a Contact sales route for Enterprise. If you want to try your own prompts before paying, both give you a way to do it, though what you get is limited by the trial days on one side and the credit allowance on the other.

Where Pineprompt fits

If you mainly need to see whether AI answers mention you, Pineprompt is a focused tracker. Every plan runs your prompts daily on five live platforms: ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode. Grok is listed but temporarily unavailable. It reports mentions, position, sentiment, cited sources, competitors and share of voice. The MCP server is on every plan, and the API and Looker Studio connector are on Professional and Business. Starter is 99 USD per month for 50 prompts and 2 monitors. There are no credits to budget, and there is no free trial.

Pineprompt is focused on monitoring, so it is not a substitute for site audits, agent traffic analytics, agent-optimized pages or content tools, and it does not cover the longer engine lists above. For side-by-side pages, see Pineprompt vs Scrunch and Pineprompt vs AthenaHQ, or read the pricing page.

How to choose

  • You want site audits and agent-optimized pages: Scrunch's pricing page lists both.
  • You want Claude, Gemini and AI Mode without a custom plan: AthenaHQ lists them on Starter; Scrunch lists them on Enterprise.
  • You prefer a published prompt count to a credit budget: Scrunch Core lists 125 prompts, though it also caps responses at 5,000 a month.
  • You want unlimited prompts and topics, and accept credit metering: AthenaHQ Starter.
  • You want to start with no payment: AthenaHQ's Essential plan, or Scrunch's seven-day trial.
  • You report through Looker Studio or the API on a lower tier: compare Pineprompt's Professional plan, because Scrunch lists both on Enterprise and AthenaHQ lists API access as an add-on.

Common questions

Does Scrunch have a free trial?

Scrunch's pricing page lists a seven-day free trial on Core. Enterprise is reached through a demo.

What is a credit on AthenaHQ?

AthenaHQ's pricing page says one credit equals one AI response. It lists 300 credits on Essential and 3,600 credits a month on Starter.

Which tool lists more engines?

On entry plans, AthenaHQ's Starter lists eleven and Scrunch's Core lists four. Scrunch's Enterprise lists nine.

Does either tool list an API?

Scrunch's pricing page lists Query API access on Enterprise. AthenaHQ's pricing page lists API access as a paid add-on on Starter.

Written by

Allan de Wit

Co-founder & Head of Product

Allan co-founded Pineprompt and leads its product. He writes about how AI platforms pick the brands they cite, and what teams can do to earn those mentions.

Keep reading

Track your brand across every AI platform.

Pineprompt monitors five live AI platforms daily, in the country and language your buyers use. See our methodology for what we capture and how.